One dead as Toronto stage collapses before Radiohead concert


Saturday, June 16, 2012 – Globe and Mail


There was a popping crack, like the sound of fireworks, then an eerie silence as Erin Peacock watched the towering stage crumple in on itself, hardware-laden canopy tipping over towards the front end of the stage, taking reams of scaffolding down with it and leaving long sticks of twisted metal behind.

The stage collapse at Downsview Park hours before what was supposed to be a Radiohead concert crushed one man to death and injured three more. A 45-year-old man was still in hospital Saturday evening with non-life-threatening injuries. Two other men were treated for minor injuries on the scene and released. All of the victims were crew members setting up the stage, police said.

The immediate aftermath of the collapse was quiet enough for Ms. Peacock to hear everyone with her in the beer tent collectively gasp as they watched – close enough to see stagehands sent scrambling, too far away to hear them shout as the stage fell.

Ambulance sirens broke the silence and snapped Ms. Peacock and her sister back to reality. The two were supposed to be bartenders at Radiohead’s Saturday night concert – a first for Ms. Peacock’s younger sister, who just got her SmartServe certification. Instead, they watched an outdoor stage become a death trap.

“We didn’t see any ambulances speeding off immediately, which led us to believe either everyone’s okay or people are pinned,” Ms. Peacock said.

It turned out to be the latter: As the top portion of the stage fell, it trapped one man beneath the debris. While a team of paramedics was already on the scene in preparation for the concert and tended quickly to the other hurt crew members, they couldn’t reach the last victim until police and firefighters managed to extricate him.

The man, believed to be in his 30s, was pronounced dead at the scene – a “crushing injury,” paramedics said.

Ms. Peacock said there were about 10 crew members on the stage when it collapsed. It seemed they were about to do a sound check – electronic twangs piping through the speakers were what made her look up just before the structure fell.

Lindsey Bradbury, an employee at Handpicked management, was preparing to work in one of the beer tents when she noticed the commotion. She said people were hanging screens on the stage just prior to the collapse.

Once the stage fell, she could hear people yelling “First aid!”

The concert facility at Downsview Park was newly renovated. Radiohead and their opener, Caribou, were to be the first performers there.

Jim Brett, president of International Alliance Theatrical Stage Employees Local 58, said crew members working on the Downsview stage weren’t members of his union.

“The only thing I can confirm is that IATSE Local 58 was not involved with the building of the stage or supplying any labour for the concert,” he wrote in an e-mail. “Regardless of who was involved, the stage collapse is a tragic event and we offer our most sincere condolences to the family of the deceased and our thoughts are with those who were injured.”

Ontario’s Labour Ministry is investigating, as is customary when there’s an accident at a worksite. Forensics, coroner and ministry investigators weren’t able to begin their work until the crumpled structred was deemed secure Saturday night. But police said subsequent events at Downsview Park – including a Sunday run for girls in Grade 3 though Grade 8 – would continue as planned.

Live Nation, the company organizing the concert, declined to comment, referring questions to a spokeswoman for Radiohead who did not return calls or text messages Saturday. Radiohead tweeted that “Due to unforeseen circumstances tonight’s [concert] at downsview park has been cancelled. Fans are advised not to make their way to the venue.”

This isn’t the first time an outdoor stage at a Canadian concert has collapsed, sometimes with fatal consequences. Several people were hurt last July when the stage at Ottawa’s Bluesfest collapsed as Cheap Trick playing. In 2009, the main stage collapsed at Alberta’s Big Valley Jamboree, near Camrose, killing one woman and injured several others. Panhandle Productions, Global Production Co. and a numbered Alberta company all faced dozens of charges coming out of the Big Valley Jamboree stage collapse, but Crown prosecutors stayed the charges in January, citing low likelihood of conviction.

A key difference, however, is the weather: Both the Bluesfest and the Big Valley collapses happened during stormy windstorms that some have said could have played a role in the accidents.

“How does something like this happen?” Ms. Peacock asked. “I’ve seen reports of stages collapsing before, but it’s always been due to weather conditions and whatnot. There was no weather condition today. It was a beautiful, warm sunny day.”

With files from Paige Ellis, Josh O’Kane and Robert Everett Green

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s